Disney Films are not as Innocent as One May Think
In "Unlearning the Myths that Bind Us", Christensen's argument may be troubling to some. Christensen argues that children's books, movies, and TV shows seldom do not include stereotypes. This is particularly alarming because by reading and watching these, according to Christensen, children are receiving a "secret education". This "secret education" is teaching children untrue and harmful stereotypes at an age when they are most impressionable.
I have chosen to focus on Disney films because there are so many examples of racism, sexism, and blatant gender stereotypes. When children watch a movie which negatively depicts a certain race, they will start to believe that this race is in fact inferior. When children watch movie after movie in which the beautiful princess is saved by her handsome prince, they are taught that looks are more important than anything else and that women need men to save them. As adults we can look at these messages and recognize that they are not true. However, children will believe that these stereotypes are true if they see, hear, and read them over and over again.
The YouTube account "Screen Rant" has a video that gives ten examples of blatant racism in Disney films. As children, we probably did not pick up on the issues with these scenes. However, children are being indoctrinated with these messages without even knowing it. The video certainly parallels Christensen's argument that children's movies often portray negative stereotypes.
Two years ago The Washington Post published an article which talks about male characters dominating Disney films. Even though the princess movies include a female as the main character, there are few other important characters in the film who are female. The statistics on the number of speaking roles female characters have in relation to male characters was shocking to me. On a more positive note, the article also discusses how some modern Disney films like Brave have been giving more significance to female characters.
I have included one more link to an article which talks about the effects of princess movies on both boys and girls. Surprisingly, boys benefitted in some ways from watching princess movies. The article also states that when parents talk to their children about other great qualities the princesses have like how smart and independent they are, the children will also want to have these wonderful qualities. The little girls who are taught to think about princesses as smart rather than just beautiful will also want to be smart and strong.
Do you think that Disney movies are making progress in terms of including less stereotypes? Or, do you feel that by eliminating certain stereotypes they are incorporating different stereotypes?
I agree with your points. It was really interesting to go back and think about how these stereotypes impacted our thinking when we were 7 or 8.
ReplyDeleteyou make some really great points. I am a huge Disney fan. to answer your question, yes I do think that Disney movies are making progress with including less sterotypes.
ReplyDeleteYou made a really good argument here. I completely agree with you. Though I love Disney, the majority of characters are always white, skinny, have perfect hair, etc. This was a very good post!
ReplyDeleteI agree with all your points, its crazy to me how many of these stereotypes have impacted little children at age 7 or 8.
ReplyDeleteAmanda,
ReplyDeleteYour argument is very strong! The video you included also help to support it. I think the pictures are equally as important, because it's so true! Children might not know it when they are watching the movies, but they really are being shaped by the expectations these movies create. Great job!
Thank you for your post. I really agreed with your points. I actually used your blog post question in my blog because I thought it was such a good question. I think that Disney has improved quite a bit in this area. The example I used was Moana, a princess of color who was not interested in prince charming I don't think. They have come along way, I think but still have further to go.
ReplyDeleteI love the pictures that you used in your blog! Your argument is well written and backed up perfectly. The stereotypes that we blindly see as children in Disney movies is crazy to see once we've grown up and realize them. Overall, good job!
ReplyDeleteDisney movies inspire little girls that they can be princesses and as we get older we literally take these things to heart. The issue is what is taught at home and the confidence we should be giving the children
ReplyDelete